By:  August 8, 2025 Categories: 

How to Identify Winning Patterns Through Journaling

Every trader wants to find their “edge”—that unique combination of setups, habits, and timing that consistently produces profits. But most traders overlook the easiest way to uncover it: journaling. Your journal isn’t just a logbook; it’s a pattern detector. When done correctly, it reveals what’s working, what’s not, and what habits you must repeat or break to stay profitable—especially during high-pressure prop firm challenges. Here’s how to identify your winning patterns step by step.

Step 1: Track Everything Consistently

You can’t find patterns if your data is incomplete. Use a structured daily journal to track each of the following:

  • Trade setup (e.g., breakout, reversal, trend continuation)
  • Time of day
  • Market instrument
  • Trade direction (long or short)
  • Entry/exit price
  • Stop-loss and take-profit levels
  • Result (win/loss/breakeven)
  • Emotional state at entry
  • Rule compliance (yes/no)

Use a mix of digital tools (like Notion or Google Sheets) and printable trackers like the Prop Firm Press Journal Sheets to ensure nothing gets missed.

Step 2: Tag or Categorize Your Trades

Over time, tag your trades with consistent labels:

  • Setup type: VWAP bounce, support/resistance, pullback
  • Market type: trending, choppy, range-bound
  • News condition: high-impact, low-impact, no news
  • Outcome: textbook win, rule break loss, partial win, emotional loss

These tags make it easy to filter and sort data later—whether you’re using Excel or a custom database.

Step 3: Calculate Win Rates by Category

Once you have at least 30–50 trades logged, group and calculate win rates by:

  • Setup
  • Day of the week
  • Time of day
  • Market type
  • Emotion tag

For example, you may find that VWAP bounce setups on Wednesdays between 10–11 a.m. have a 70% win rate, while breakouts during news events only win 30% of the time. These are gold nuggets for your trading plan.

Step 4: Highlight Top 3 Performing Setups

Take your highest-performing categories and document them separately:

  • What do they look like on the chart?
  • What conditions must be present?
  • What entry trigger works best?
  • Where do you usually place stops and exits?

Write them out like a playbook. Print screenshots. Add annotations. These setups become your go-to strategy during prop firm challenges when consistency is key.

Step 5: Spot Emotional Sabotage Patterns

Your journal should track not just your trades, but your state of mind:

  • Do you take more losses when you’re angry or tired?
  • Do you enter too early after a previous loss?
  • Do you skip good setups after two wins?

Winning patterns aren’t just about setups—they’re about behavior. Journaling exposes these behavioral cycles and helps you stay in control.

Step 6: Use Visual Cues

Use charts with annotations to spot visual patterns. Highlight:

  • Where price reversed unexpectedly
  • Where you hesitated to enter a winning setup
  • Where your exit was too early or too late

Images help your brain recognize context that raw numbers can’t. Journaling with screenshots makes it easier to replicate good trades and avoid bad ones.

Step 7: Track Rule Breaks

One of the biggest negative patterns that hurts performance is rule breaking. Add a rule compliance checkbox to each entry:

  • Did I follow risk management?
  • Did I follow trade limits?
  • Did I wait for confirmation?
  • Did I trade during allowed hours?

Now, look for a pattern in when rule breaks happen. Is it after a losing streak? On Fridays? During news? Spotting this allows you to create fail-safes—like mandatory breaks or maximum loss stops.

Step 8: Create a “Best Trades” Archive

Make a folder, spreadsheet tab, or physical binder titled “Best Trades.” Only include trades that:

  • Followed your plan
  • Were executed cleanly
  • Produced high RR
  • Felt psychologically strong

This is your evidence file. Reviewing it regularly reminds you what success looks like and builds confidence heading into any funded evaluation.

Step 9: Reassess Monthly

Set a calendar reminder for the end of each month. Open your journal and ask:

  • Which setups are producing results?
  • What mistakes am I still repeating?
  • Is my emotional control improving?
  • Should I drop or add a strategy?

This structured review prevents stagnation. You’re always iterating. Always improving.

Step 10: Turn Data into Rules

Once you know your patterns, turn them into hard rules. For example:

  • I only trade from 9:30–11:00 a.m. EST
  • I will not trade after 2 consecutive losses
  • I will only enter VWAP bounces with confirmation
  • I stop for the day after hitting my daily goal

These rules make trading simpler and more mechanical—exactly what you need to pass challenges with confidence.

Don’t Ignore the Small Wins

Many winning patterns start subtle. A small 1R win on a clean reversal might be your most scalable edge, even if it doesn’t feel impressive. Journaling helps you stack those micro-wins until they form a powerful foundation.

Final Thought

Prop firm challenges are designed to test your consistency. Journaling gives you the feedback loop to find out what’s already working—and double down on it. Patterns are always hiding in your trades. The only question is: are you tracking them closely enough to see them?

Leave a Reply